19 October 2026 | 10 min read
Soumya Ranjan Bihara
From narrow entrances and dim corridors to commercial stalls and VIP lanes, the Chorbagan tragedy raises a larger question: are the spaces built to welcome thousands prepared to protect them when something goes wrong?
Nineteen people died at the Chorbagan Sarbojanin Durga Puja pandal in north Kolkata on Saturday, 17 October. Police say a sudden spell of rain brought a rush of visitors, and that narrow gates, weak crowd control and an announcement warning that the structure might collapse all added to the panic. The investigation is still under way and no final findings have been released.
For the families who lost someone, the festival ended in a way they could never have imagined. A 25-year-old Sonu Pal has said he watched his mother die during the crush.
Investigators must establish what happened and who, if anyone, failed in their duties. But the tragedy also raises a wider question. When a pandal is designed to attract thousands of visitors, is equal attention paid to the space they need to enter, move around and leave safely?
Kolkata has heard this warning before
In 2015, the 88-foot idol at Deshapriya Park drew such large crowds that traffic across south Kolkata came to a standstill. Police eventually stopped public access to the pandal, citing the risk to visitors.
In 2021, crowd surges at Sreebhumi in Lake Town showed again how hard it is to manage large numbers at a major attraction.
These incidents differed in scale and outcome from Chorbagan. They do not prove a direct line of responsibility leading to this tragedy. They do show that the risks of narrow streets, large crowds and sudden surges have been visible for years.
The real question is whether the lessons from those incidents have reached individual pandals, including those that draw large crowds because of their theme, scale or popularity.
The UNESCO guidelines that deserve a closer look
A useful starting point already exists. In 2025, UNESCO and the United Nations Resident Coordinator’s Office, working with IIT Kharagpur, released a practical guide on applying principles of inclusion and universal design in Durga Puja pandals. It covers physical access, entrances and exits, movement inside pandals, lighting, information systems, emergency evacuation and volunteer training.
The guide treats access as a matter of dignity and participation, not as a facility for a small group of visitors. It is written mainly for people with disabilities, older people, pregnant women and children, whose needs are often overlooked when the focus is on moving large numbers through a pandal. Its safety provisions, however, apply to everyone.
For the accessible path inside a pandal, the guide sets a minimum width of 1.5 metres. Where objects project into the path, the clear width should never fall below 900 millimetres. For the route from the drop-off point to the pandal, it recommends 1.8 metres at high-traffic pandals. These are accessibility provisions. They are not a formula for how many people a pandal can safely hold.
For an accessible entrance, the guide specifies a clear width of at least one metre, preferably 1.5 metres. The entrance should sit beside the main gate and be physically separated or cordoned off to prevent overcrowding.
The guide also calls for a rehearsed evacuation plan, clearly marked emergency routes and exits that lead to open areas large enough for the expected peak crowd. Emergency routes should have lighting that runs on a power supply separate from the main source.
When the entrance becomes the danger point
I visited Kolkata from 15 to 18 October. At some pandals, the space left for people entering looked limited. At some locations, advertising installations and temporary stalls stood close to the pandal or its approach. These are my observations, not a citywide survey, and they need to be checked against the layout and permissions of each site.
The concern is not simply whether a queue looks crowded. A crowd turns dangerous when people arrive faster than a narrow passage can take them, when those inside cannot leave, or when a sudden change forces visitors to reverse direction. A 2014 report by the National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA), India’s apex body for disaster management, noted that most crowd disasters in India and other developing countries occur at religious gatherings. Such incidents have repeatedly raised concerns about crowd safety at large religious events across the country.
At Chorbagan, police said that both the gates and the approach road were narrow, and that people tried to escape through the entrance during the crush. Investigators are examining the sequence of events, including the rain and the announcement.
A narrow entrance does not, by itself, prove that a pandal is unsafe. But when many visitors must pass through a constricted route, organisers need to show how entry is regulated, how people inside can leave and how emergency responders can reach the site.
The questions are straightforward. How many people can safely be inside the pandal at one time? Who keeps that count? Is there room outside the entrance for people to wait without blocking a public road? Can the flow be stopped before pressure builds? Can visitors leave without meeting a fresh wave of people coming in? The answers should come from site plans, measurements, expected footfall and crowd arrangements, not from how the place looks on the day.
The commercial space around the pandal
Sponsorship and advertising are part of the economics of modern Durga Puja. Food stalls, merchandise counters and temporary commercial structures also form part of the visitor experience. But their placement needs careful examination when the space around a pandal is already limited.
A stall near an entrance may cause no trouble on an ordinary evening. The same obstruction can matter badly when a crowd suddenly surges towards or away from the gate.
After the Chorbagan incident, West Bengal’s fire services department had issued notices to three south Kolkata puja committees after inspections raised safety concerns. The committees are Chetla Agrani, Ballygunge Cultural Association and Tridhara Sammilani. Officials ordered the removal of unauthorised commercial structures near pandals and flagged LPG cylinders kept close to highly inflammable materials.
These notices are not proof that every commercial installation is dangerous, or that the named committees caused the Chorbagan deaths. Tridhara Sammilani said it had obtained the department’s no-objection certificate before opening its pandal, and that it had submitted a compliance report explaining its safety and crowd-control arrangements. The notices do strengthen the case for examining how temporary structures are approved, placed and inspected.
Organisers should be able to show that stalls and installations do not block exits, emergency routes or the space needed for safe movement. Officials should check the layout after stalls and decorations have been installed, rather than relying only on a plan drawn up before the festival.
Lighting and ventilation are part of safety
A pandal is often designed to create a particular atmosphere. Darkness, carefully placed lights, winding passages and dramatic views of the idol can be central to the artistic idea. But the experience should not come at the cost of visitors’ ability to move safely.
The UNESCO guide calls for safe, illuminated routes and independent lighting for emergency evacuation. It also addresses ventilation in resting areas and the need for clear wayfinding.
After Chorbagan, inspection teams asked for enough lighting to remove dark stretches inside pandals, along with better ventilation, including fans or air-conditioning where needed.
Poor visibility makes it harder to see steps, negotiate turns, spot someone who has fallen or follow instructions during an emergency. These are risks that can be assessed through inspection, without assuming that lighting alone caused the tragedy. Ventilation deserves attention too, especially in enclosed spaces where people wait for long periods.
The question for organisers is whether lighting and ventilation are checked as safety requirements, and not only as design features. Emergency lights should work when the main supply fails, and exits should remain identifiable even when the design depends on darkness.
VIP access and the ordinary visitor
A VIP entrance or separate queue is not automatically unsafe. But it must not interfere with the movement or safety of the general public.
At a crowded pandal, the practical questions matter most. Are VIP and public routes physically separated? Do their queues cross? Does a special entrance create a bottleneck somewhere else? Are enough police and volunteers deployed at the busiest points, rather than clustered around one gate?
Local residents told media that police deployment at Chorbagan was inadequate, and that most personnel were stationed near the VIP entrance rather than where footfall was heaviest. This is an allegation made during the investigation. That allegation needs checking. Investigators should establish where police and security staff were posted, what instructions they had and whether their numbers matched the movement of the crowd.
The principle should be the same for everyone. No special arrangement should compromise the safety of ordinary visitors. If a site nears its safe capacity, entry should stop, whoever is waiting outside.
Volunteers need training, not just instructions
Volunteers are often the first people visitors meet when queues stall or a problem starts. Their work can make a real difference, but they cannot manage an emergency without preparation and clear authority.
The UNESCO guide asks for volunteers trained in emergency situations, in respectful help for older people and people with disabilities, and in the use of essential emergency contacts. It recommends mandatory pre-Puja emergency drills and simulation exercises. The same guide says essential announcements should be repeated in several languages, and that emergency alarms should give clear directions to exits.
These provisions matter in light of reports that an announcement warning of a possible collapse may have added to the panic at Chorbagan. Police are trying to identify who made the announcement and what prompted it. Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari has said that family members of two of the deceased claimed whistles blown by private security guards triggered a rush. Police are checking eyewitness accounts and CCTV footage to establish the sequence of events.
An emergency message has to be accurate, authorised and understood. A warning about real danger should never be replaced by vague or conflicting instructions. Genuine danger, however, must be communicated without delay, with clear directions about where people should move.
Volunteers need to know who can stop entry, how to reach the police, when to call for medical help and how to stop an already crowded area from becoming more congested. Organisers should be able to show that volunteers have practised these steps before the festival begins.
Rain, sudden changes and emergency planning
The Chorbagan incident shows why weather and crowd behaviour have to be planned for together. Police say the sudden downpour caused a surge of visitors looking for shelter, and that the resulting movement worsened the crush.
A crowd plan should consider what happens when visitors suddenly stop, turn back or try to enter a covered space at the same time. It should name safe holding areas, set out when entry must be suspended and make sure no one is directed into a passage that is already packed.
The National Disaster Management Authority’s crowd-management guidance supports measures such as regulating entry, providing adequate holding areas, separating routes where necessary and monitoring congestion before it becomes dangerous.
No plan can predict everything. But a sudden downpour, a medical emergency or a structural concern should never leave organisers and visitors without a workable plan.
Visitors have responsibilities too
Visitors can reduce risk by following police instructions, respecting barriers and avoiding attempts to push past queues. If an area looks packed, waiting or going to another pandal may be safer than trying to get in.
People should also watch for exit signs, keep children close and avoid blocking routes while taking photographs. In a tightly packed crowd, they should not push against the flow. They should alert nearby officials when someone falls or needs medical attention.
But public cooperation cannot replace proper planning. Visitors cannot be expected to calculate a pandal’s safe capacity, spot an obstructed emergency route or correct an inadequate security deployment. Responsibility for a safe venue rests with the organisers and with the authorities who inspect and manage crowds. Visitors should follow instructions, but they should not be blamed for failures they had no power to prevent.
From inspection to accountability
After the tragedy, the state government announced a review of safety arrangements at major pandals where inspectors were examining entrances, exits, lighting and other safety measures.
The Chief Minister has ordered a Special Investigation Team headed by a sitting Calcutta High Court judge, with members from the STF, CID and other departments. He has promised action against anyone found to have failed in crowd management. Police have detained people, including organisers of the Chorbagan puja, and prohibitory orders are in force on roads around the pandal until 20 October.
The immediate priority is to establish the facts and decide responsibility on the basis of evidence. The longer task is to make sure inspections lead to real change, rather than ending with notices, meetings and temporary restrictions.
Committees should be able to show that their approved plans match the structures and routes used during the festival. Authorities should verify crowd capacity, access and exit arrangements, emergency lighting, the position of commercial stalls and the availability of trained staff. High-footfall pandals should have rehearsed emergency plans and a clear system for stopping entry when conditions become unsafe.
The UNESCO guide offers a useful foundation for making the festival more accessible and dignified. Its provisions on clear routes, evacuation, lighting, communication and volunteer training can help organisers find weak points before visitors arrive. But their implementation must be assessed alongside the separate requirements of fire safety, structural safety and crowd management.
The city also needs a clear answer on how compliance is checked, who is authorised to halt entry, and what happens when a committee fails to correct a serious hazard. These questions matter for the biggest attractions, and also for neighbourhood pandals where narrow streets and small spaces can make emergency access difficult.
Durga Puja belongs to the people who celebrate it. Its artistic ambition and economic importance cannot be weighed separately from the safety of those who come to see it.
Kolkata can have spectacular pandals and safe ones together. What it needs is for design, crowd control and emergency planning to be worked out as one job.
A pandal should be judged not only by how many people it draws, but by whether every visitor can enter, see the celebration and leave safely, even when something goes wrong.



